At a clinic within the north of Pretoria, a pregnant lady tried to register as a affected person within the facility’s antenatal care utilizing a South African id doc (ID) with a photograph that didn’t match her face.
It additional emerged that the lady had just lately been turned away from one other clinic on account of inappropriate documentation.
The clinic matron referred to as the police to resolve the dispute and to evaluate the authenticity of the ID.
However previous to that, the lady obtained care. “The employees ensured that the affected person’s vitals had been taken, earlier than handing her over to SAPS, which resonates with the Batho Pele Precept,” the matron tells Well being-e Information.
Healthcare staff should confirm id
“As healthcare suppliers, we’re anticipated to file affected person identifiers, together with identify, ID/passport quantity, date of start, contact particulars to register information,” the matron tells Well being-e Information, “to make sure affordable efforts to confirm id for medical information, billing/medical schemes, continuity of care, prescriptions, and medico-legal documentation.”
She says that this obligation arises from the Nationwide Well being Act, the Well being Professions Council of South Africa’s moral guidelines and correct affected person information, and the Safety of Private Data Act.
“Nevertheless, healthcare staff usually are not law-enforcement officers and we aren’t anticipated to authenticate paperwork like Dwelling Affairs or SAPS.”
She explains there’s no nationwide medical protocol, however customary apply is to not confront or accuse the affected person, however to file the discrepancy factually in medical notes. “The nurse and admin clerk did properly to tell me as a facility and operational supervisor”, she says.
“The aim was to not scare the affected person however to maintain her calm and never alert her that one thing was up. The nurses’response was to comply with inner facility coverage, which included escalation to SAPS. If there’s a necessity, the police will additional escalate it to the house affairs division.”
Subscribe to our e-newsletter
Dr Angelique Coetzee, Vice-Chairperson of the Unity Discussion board of Household Practitioners (UFFP), tells Well being-e Information that clinicians ought to by no means detain a affected person or seize paperwork. “No regulation obliges clinicians to carry out immigration or id enforcement.”
“Healthcare staff are protected in the event that they act in good religion, comply with inner coverage, escalate by way of administration channels, and don’t breach confidentiality unnecessarily. They need to keep away from public disclosure, social media, and private communication with police,” she says, emphasising that authorized safety could come up from HPCSA moral safety, together with whistleblower rules and POPIA compliance.
Confidentiality is vital
An important precept in healthcare companies is the necessity to stability confidentiality and authorized duties.
“Healthcare comes first. Legislation enforcement comes second. Due to this fact, clinicians should present care no matter nationality or documentation (emergency and first care). Preserve confidentiality. Solely disclose info when required by regulation, ordered by courtroom, or the place there’s a critical public danger,” she says, including that routine id fraud doesn’t override the obligation of care.
Gauteng SAPS spokesperson Colonel Dimakatso Nevhuhulwi says the related police station responded to the incident. “There isn’t a file of any arrest of a pregnant international nationwide lady; nonetheless, the matter was escalated to the Division of Dwelling Affairs for additional investigations.”
The Division of Dwelling Affairs didn’t reply to our question. – Well being-e Information
*The identify of the power and the matron are being withheld because the matron spoke to Heath-e Information on the situation of anonymity.
